A Los Angeles jury awarded $50 million to Michael Garcia, a delivery driver who suffered severe burns when hot water spilled on him at a Starbucks drive-through in 2020. The jury unanimously found Starbucks 100% liable and ruled 11-1 that Garcia bore no negligence. His lawyers argued that the spill caused life-altering injuries, while Starbucks contended that his pre-existing diabetes contributed to his struggles.
The case, decided after brief jury deliberations, centered on surveillance footage showing the cup tipping over shortly after the handoff, allegedly due to improper securing. While Starbucks intends to appeal, the verdict highlights the potential for significant damages in personal injury lawsuits involving corporate negligence.
This case highlights several key aspects of personal injury law that are important for both plaintiffs and businesses to consider:
- Strict Liability and Negligence – The jury’s decision to hold Starbucks 100% liable suggests that businesses can be found strictly responsible for unsafe practices, even in seemingly routine transactions. This underscores the importance of proper safety measures when handling potentially hazardous products.
- The Role of Evidence – Surveillance footage played a crucial role in proving liability. Video evidence can be a decisive factor in personal injury cases, helping juries determine fault and negligence.
- High-Stakes Damages – The $50 million award demonstrates that juries may be willing to grant substantial compensation when injuries significantly impact a victim’s life. While Starbucks argued for a lower amount, the jury ultimately sided with the plaintiff, indicating that emotional and long-term physical damages can greatly influence the outcome.
This case serves as a reminder of the importance of legal representation in personal injury claims. Victims facing large corporations should work with experienced attorneys to ensure they receive fair compensation for their injuries. Plaintiff in this matter is represented by Nicholas Rowley of Trial Lawyers for Justice and Daniel Bidegaray of Bidegaray Law Firm LLC.
Were you or someone you know burned or injured as a result of another’s or a business’s negligence? Contact Anzalone & Doyle Trial Lawyers today for a free consultation regarding your potential Personal Injury Negligence case.
